Is Manchester United judged more harshly due to its stature?

Manchester United Women have returned to the spotlight following the departure of former manager Marc Skinner. Since the team was professionalised in 2018, the club has faced widespread criticism regarding perceived underinvestment. Issues frequently raised include quiet transfer windows, the exit of high-profile players, a lack of silverware, and concerns over training facilities. Tensions have also emerged between the club and media, notably when The Athletic was barred from asking questions at a post-match press conference last season. Before his departure, Skinner had indirectly expressed frustration over squad investment. Despite leading the team to two top-three WSL finishes, three consecutive FA Cup finals, their first major trophy, and a Champions League quarter-final, he faced significant fan unrest, with calls for his dismissal at Leigh Sports Village in 2024. Criticism extended beyond results to performances against rivals Arsenal, Chelsea, and Manchester City, echoing concerns raised by former manager Casey Stoney, who resigned in 2021 citing a lack of resources. Although United professionalised in 2018 and signed England internationals like Alex Greenwood, they have secured only one major trophy in eight years and currently risk falling behind rivals. Reports in 2024 highlighted inadequate training facilities when the women's team moved to temporary buildings to accommodate the men's squad at Carrington. Comments by co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe also drew scrutiny; he described the men's team as the "main issue" and referred to the women's team as "the girls" and "an opportunity." The club has also lost key staff, including assistant Martin Ho and goalkeeping coach Ian Wilcock to Tottenham, and former assistant Charlotte Healy to Bristol City. High-profile player departures include Alessia Russo, Mary Earps, Ona Batlle, and Melvine Malard, the latter sold to Chelsea for £850,000 without a direct replacement. However, BBC Sport notes that United is not alone in facing such scrutiny. While the men's team's success drives higher expectations, clubs like Liverpool, West Ham, and Tottenham have also faced criticism. Tottenham struggled for years before recent improvements, while West Ham remains the only WSL side not to play at their men's stadium and has faced criticism over transfer activity and structural instability. Liverpool faced severe backlash following their 2020 relegation and allegations from former players regarding contract withdrawals. Even Chelsea, despite six consecutive WSL titles, has faced criticism for limiting Stamford Bridge capacity for Champions League matches and manager Sonia Bompastor's calls for greater squad depth. Ultimately, while Manchester United faces intense scrutiny, the decision-making and progress of many WSL clubs remain under close observation.